Early withdrawal penalty

To discourage individuals from using money set aside in retirement accounts for expenses incurred outside of retirement, a 10 percent tax is imposed on the amount that is withdrawn, in addition to this amount being included in the individual’s gross income and subject to federal (and often, state) income tax. The 10 percent penalty will not apply to distributions made in the following circumstances:

• After the individual has reached age 59 1/2;
• The distribution is made to an individual who is a beneficiary of a deceased IRA owner;
• The individual is disabled;
• For higher education expenses (from IRAs only);
• The distributions are made as part of substantially equal payments over the account holder’s life expectancy;
• The individual retires after age 55;
• For unreimbursed medical expenses exceeding 7.5 percent of the individual’s adjusted gross income (AGI);
• For medical insurance premiums in the case of unemployment;
• To buy, build, or rebuild a first home (from IRAs only, and subject to a $10,000 withdrawal limit); and
• If the individual is a reservist called to active duty after September 11, 2001.

Caution: The extent to which withdrawal may be made from an employer-sponsored qualified retirement plan, even with respect to amounts that you contributed, depends upon what is allowed under the written plan itself. Some plans don’t allow you to withdraw only after retire. Others allow withdrawals for “hardships,” which may include medical expenses or other financial crisis. Still other withdrawals, however, such as withdrawals for higher education or a first home purchase, are never allowed under IRS rules from an employer-run. The 10 percent penalty and, for that matter, the underlying taxable income generated from a withdrawal, do not apply if the funds are properly rolled over within a 60-day period from an employer-sponsored plan to an IRA or from one qualified plan or IRA to another.

Hardship withdrawals. Individuals who take hardship withdrawal from their defined contribution plan must also pay the 10 percent penalty tax. A hardship is defined as an immediate and heavy financial need. Certain expenses are deemed to meet this definition, but even so, the penalty still applies.

Proposals to suspend the 10 percent penalty

Several proposals have been advanced by policymakers to eliminate or suspend the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty in certain situations. The proposals would generally add a paragraph to Internal Revenue Code Sec. 72(t) to eliminate the penalty in specific circumstances. Proposals include eliminating or suspending the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty for:

• Public safety employees who retire before the age of 55;
• Workers who are unemployed;
• Individuals affected by natural disasters;
• Homeowners at risk of having their mortgage foreclosed;
• Individuals who receive a hardship distribution from a retirement plan; and
• Individuals who have qualified adoption expenses.

RMDs

Individuals with certain qualified retirement plans, as well as traditional IRAs and 403(b) plans, are required to withdraw a certain amount ( a “required minimum distribution” or RMD) from the account each year after reaching age 70 1/2 (Roth IRAs are not subject to the RMD rules). The annual RMD is based on the account balance as of December 31 of the prior year and the account holder’s life expectancy. Generally, RMDs must begin no later than April 1 of the year after you reach age 70 1/2.

Proposals to suspend RMDs

RMDs were suspended for 2009 only. RMDs must be taken for 2010 and beyond, unless Congress acts to suspend the RMD rules again. However policymakers have put forth various proposals to eliminate or suspend altogether the RMD requirements. The proposals include:

• Suspending the RMD requirement through 2010;
• Suspending the RMD requirement through 2012;
• Eliminating the RMD requirement; or
• Postponing the required starting date, which would raise the age at which individuals must start taking their RMDs.

When contemplating whether to implement any of these proposals, Congress and Treasury officials must balance a number of considerations, including the immediate financial needs of individuals with the policies behind the penalty taxes; namely, providing funds for retirement and not allowing the money to be used for pre-retirement expenses.

Our office will keep you posted on any legislative proposals that may affect your retirement planning. We also can help you navigate the current rules that would apply should you need to make a withdrawal soon from your retirement savings.